MatthewSean Reviews

Book reviews, movie reviews, and other writing

Book Review – Code Name Verity – Elizabeth Wein — May 8, 2017

Book Review – Code Name Verity – Elizabeth Wein

Book Review – Code Name Verity – Elizabeth Wein

code_name_verity

Facts:

Book: Code Name Verity
Author: Elizabeth Wein
Genre: Young Adult Fiction
Year of Release: 2012
Read 343-page hardcover edition in May 2017.

Book Description:

Two best friends, Maddie and Julie, are working for different areas of the Allied forces in World War II.  When their plane goes down in France during a critical moment in time, they are separated, neither one wondering if the other is alive or dead. Julie finds herself held by the Germans, and Maddie is being hidden by Allied sympathizers in a French town under German control.

While the two figure out what to do about their situations, a tale of friendship and courage emerges.

Book Review:

This WWII story marketed at an older teenage audience has gotten rave reviews on Goodreads and similar websites. Although I can definitely see the attraction of the novel, I had mixed thoughts about the work by author Elizabeth Wein.

One element of the novel I enjoyed was the fact that it was told in two parts, by each of the two main characters, based on their points of view, and what happened to them before, during, and after the plane crash. This was an interesting way to tell the story, and reveal what happened. As we read the second part, we learned things that we thought we knew from the first part, but that were wrong after all. Wein did a nice job of misleading the reader in some places, and creating some tension by doing so, as we weren’t sure what might happen.

That being said, there were some obvious “clues” interspersed in the first part of the novel, where specific lines and items were underlined. These were later used by the Allied forces as clues from Julie from her time in prison. There were some logical plot holes with how she was able to keep getting permission to write these clues, long after the value she was providing from her tale was over. There were several additional issues with regard to logic in the  plot and storyline which detracted from the novel.

Wein also did a good job creating some memorable characters, in particular Maggie and Julie. It was enjoyable to read about two female lead characters who did not have romantic relationships with males in the novel. This decision by Wein allowed us to focus on the female leads and their many strong character traits. Furthermore, their friendship was well explored and very interesting.

One additional item which may be detracting from the fast-paced nature of the novel was the scenes, particularly early in the novel, where a lot of dialogue and detail was provided on plane mechanics and operations. Although this would be valuable for someone with that specific set of interests, at times the level of detail was a little much.

The climax of the novel, without giving it away, was truly shocking. Although the scene again had some questionable elements in it that didn’t make a lot of sense (when did Maddie become such a good shot?), the scene itself was definitely intense, emotional, and surprising, and Wein made a strong decision to have this in the novel.

Overall, although this novel did suffer from some problems, it did pull a punch.

Overall: 2.5 stars out of 5 stars

Advertisements
Categories: Book Reviews

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: